What Happened to Watson (Karelia Software)?
Watson was a pioneering Mac OS X desktop application developed by Karelia Software, launched in 2001, that provided internet content through plug-ins. Its innovative approach was famously replicated by Apple's Sherlock 3, leading to the coining of the term "Sherlocked." Development of Watson ceased in 2004, and its developer, Karelia Software, appears to have become defunct by 2023.
Quick Answer
Watson, a desktop web productivity application by Karelia Software, was discontinued in 2004 after Apple released Sherlock 3 with similar features, a phenomenon now known as "Sherlocking." Karelia Software made the final version of Watson free. As of 2026, Karelia Software itself appears to be defunct, with its later product, Sandvox, no longer functioning and support channels unresponsive since at least 2023.
📊Key Facts
📅Complete Timeline10 events
Watson is officially released by Karelia Software
Karelia Software launches Watson, a desktop application for Mac OS X designed to provide internet content via plug-ins.
Apple releases Sherlock 3, sparking 'Sherlocked' controversy
Apple bundles Sherlock 3 with Mac OS X v10.2, featuring functionalities highly similar to Watson, leading to accusations of copying and coining the term 'Sherlocked'.
Steve Jobs' 'Handcar' comment to Dan Wood
Steve Jobs reportedly tells Karelia owner Dan Wood that Karelia is a 'handcar in the way of the steam train that owns the tracks,' highlighting Apple's dominant position.
Sun Microsystems licenses Watson technology
Sun Microsystems announces it has licensed Watson's technology to port it to Java under the codename 'Project Alameda'.
Development of Cocoa-based Watson ceases
Karelia Software officially stops development of the Cocoa-based version of Watson for Mac OS X.
Last version of Watson released for free
Dan Wood, Karelia owner, makes the final version of Watson available free of charge by posting a registration code on his blog.
Karelia's Sandvox receives Apple Design Award recognition
Karelia Software's later product, Sandvox (a website builder), gains a runner-up position in the Apple Design Awards, indicating continued activity for the company post-Watson.
Wikipedia pages for Karelia Software and Sandvox deleted
Wikipedia discussions conclude with the deletion of the 'Karelia Software' and 'Sandvox' pages due to a lack of sufficient notability, suggesting a decline in public presence.
Users report Karelia Software appears defunct
An Apple Community forum post indicates that Sandvox no longer works and Karelia Software seems to be out of business, with no responses to support inquiries.
Current status: Watson remains discontinued, Karelia Software defunct
As of today, Watson remains a discontinued product, and its original developer, Karelia Software, shows no signs of active operation or support, effectively being defunct.
Follow this story
Get an email when this timeline gets a major update.
🔍Deep Dive Analysis
Watson was a groundbreaking desktop application for Mac OS X, launched by Karelia Software on November 27, 2001. It aimed to provide users with internet content, such as weather, stock quotes, and movie listings, through a user-friendly interface powered by plug-ins. This approach was novel, blending web services with a native desktop experience.
The application's trajectory took a dramatic turn on September 18, 2002, when Apple released Mac OS X v10.2, which included Sherlock 3. Sherlock 3 incorporated features strikingly similar to Watson's, prompting accusations from Karelia Software and its advocates that Apple had copied their product without permission or compensation. This incident became a seminal moment in the Mac developer community, giving rise to the term "Sherlocked" – a phenomenon where Apple introduces a first-party feature that directly competes with and often supplants a successful third-party application. Steve Jobs reportedly conveyed to Karelia owner Dan Wood that Karelia was merely a "handcar in the way of the steam train that owns the tracks."
Despite the controversy, Watson continued development for a period. In June 2004, Sun Microsystems licensed the Watson technology with plans to port it to the Java programming language under the name "Project Alameda." However, the Cocoa-based development of Watson for Mac OS X officially ceased on October 5, 2004. The final version of Watson was subsequently released free of charge by Dan Wood on his blog on November 24, 2004.
While Watson itself faded, Karelia Software continued to develop other applications, most notably Sandvox, a website creation tool. Sandvox even received an Apple Design Award runner-up position in 2007. However, the long-term fate of Karelia Software appears to be one of quiet dissolution. By March 2023, users reported that Sandvox no longer worked, and attempts to contact Karelia Software support went unanswered, leading to the conclusion that the company had gone out of business. Further evidence of its decline includes the deletion of Wikipedia pages for "Karelia Software" and "Sandvox" in December 2021 due to lack of notability. As of September 2026, there is no indication that Karelia Software is still operational or that Watson has any active development or support. The legacy of Watson primarily lives on through the term "Sherlocked," which remains a relevant concept in the developer community.
What If...?
Explore alternate histories. What if Watson (Karelia Software) made different choices?